next up previous
Next: P from the partition function Up: Chapter 6 Previous: Chapter 6

P from a Canonical Ensemble Average

The objective is the average gas pressure P. Consider the canonical ensemble for a volume of ideal gas. Each element of the ensemble contains N gas molecules (here taken to be points having mass m that do not interact with each other) within in a volume V. V could be an tex2html_wrap_inline609 cube defined by the six planes ( x = 0, L); (y = 0, L); (z = 0, L); shape considerations reappear in the homework. T enters via the canonical statistical weight tex2html_wrap_inline615 , because tex2html_wrap_inline617 .

The pressure is the force which the gas exerts on the walls of its container. In order for this force to exist, there must exist a gas-wall potential U(s), s being the distance from the wall to a particular atom. The force exerted on the wall by a single atom is tex2html_wrap_inline623 , tex2html_wrap_inline625 being the unit vector normal to the wall. U(s) is assumed to be short range, i. e., U(s) = 0 for tex2html_wrap_inline631 , tex2html_wrap_inline633 being a non-infinitesimal distance with tex2html_wrap_inline635 . For typical forces, tex2html_wrap_inline637 , while tex2html_wrap_inline639 m in conventional apparatus, so tex2html_wrap_inline635 is not a stringent requirement. The atoms cannot pass beyond the walls, so tex2html_wrap_inline643 as tex2html_wrap_inline645 , and similarly for the other walls. The pressure P depends on the exact position of the gas atoms, so P varies from element to element of the canonical ensemble. Similarly, in a real system P fluctuates in time, changing as the gas molecules move within their container.

Figure 6-1 sketches representative elements of the ensemble. Small circles are atoms; the dashed line represents the range of the atom-wall potential. The atoms are assumed to exert no forces on each other. While the atoms are moving, a correct representation of a single element of the ensemble shows atoms at a single instant in time, atoms at each instant having given, specified values of position and momentum. The force on the wall arises from the atom-wall potential, which is short range, so in Figure 6-1a two atoms are exerting a force on the wall. On the other hand, in the element of the ensemble represented by 6-1b only one atom is contacting the wall.

As seen in Figure 6-1, P is not the same in every element of the ensemble. The ensemble average gives an average behavior, values of P in different elements of the ensemble being spread around the average value. The variation tex2html_wrap_inline657 around the average is a calculable quantity. Pressure fluctuations in macroscopic containers are not large, with respect to measurements made using apparatus of the first kind, as discussed in Lecture 5.

 
Figure 6.1: Representative elements of the canonical ensemble. Representative elements of the canonical ensemble for the N-atom gas. Dashed line represents the outermost range of the atom-wall potential.

For simplicity, limit the calculation to the force which the gas exerts on the wall at x = 0, neglecting interactions between gas atoms and other walls of the container. (Problem 6-5 eliminates this simplification) The total energy of the system is

  equation39

where tex2html_wrap_inline663 is the potential energy of atom i, and tex2html_wrap_inline667 is the distance between atom i and the wall.

The pressure is tex2html_wrap_inline671 , <F> being the magnitude of the ensemble-average force that the gas exerts on the container, the minus sign appearing because an outwards force corresponds to a positive pressure. For this ensemble,

  equation58

To evaluate eq. 6.3, the outer sum on i may be taken outside the integrals. All terms of the sum are identical except for label, permitting the replacement tex2html_wrap_inline677 (identical terms) tex2html_wrap_inline679 (one term). The tex2html_wrap_inline681 factors into terms depending only on tex2html_wrap_inline683 or only on tex2html_wrap_inline685 , so the 6N-dimensional integral can be factored into a product of simpler integrals. The momentum integrals all have the form tex2html_wrap_inline687 , as evaluated in Lecture 4, and all cancel between numerator and denominator. The integrals over the position coordinates of each particle include terms tex2html_wrap_inline689 , which also cancel between numerator and denominator, leaving

  equation94

The integrand in the numerator of eq. 6.4 is an exact differential having value tex2html_wrap_inline691 . In the denominator

  equation108

On the rhs of eq. 6.5, in the second term U(x) is always zero, so the second term is simply tex2html_wrap_inline695 . Since tex2html_wrap_inline635 , the tex2html_wrap_inline699 covers only a very small region. Neglecting the first term, and approximating tex2html_wrap_inline701 for the second term, eqs. 6.4 and 6.5 show

  equation122

tex2html_wrap_inline703 being the volume of the box. Eq. 6.6 is the ideal gas law.

The detailed form of the repulsive wall-atom potential does not appear in final result, eq. 6.6. So long as U(x) is short range, and diverges as tex2html_wrap_inline645 , the numerator of eq. 6.4 is independent of the detailed form of U(x). However, the analysis of eq. 6.5 did incorporate an implicit assumption as to the form of U(x). The rhs of eq. 6.5 was taken to be dominated by its second term, i. e., we approximated

  equation133

If U(x) for tex2html_wrap_inline715 is negative, and sufficiently large in magnitude, the above inequality fails. Indeed, for sufficiently negative U(x) one can have tex2html_wrap_inline719 and

  equation140

 
Figure 6.2: Forms for the wall-atom potential energy U(x).

Figure 6.2 contrasts a potential appropriate for eq. 6.8 with a simple repulsive potential. If eq. 6.8 were true, one would have

  equation151

and tex2html_wrap_inline723 .

Eqs. 6.7 - 6.9, while presented as a mathematical exercise, correspond to an important physical phenomenon. Consider the hackneyed 22.4 liter container, filled at 273 K with tex2html_wrap_inline725 moles of benzene ( tex2html_wrap_inline727 ) vapor. A freshman chemistry exercise predicts for this system P of tex2html_wrap_inline731 atmosphere. Suppose, however, that the container is constructed not of stainless steel but of activated charcoal! Activated charcoal strongly adsorbs most aromatic compounds, including benzene. Adsorption is well-described by the potential of eq. 6.8 and Fig. 6.2. Close to the wall, the molecule finds itself in a very deep potential well which, if the kinetic energy of the molecule is not too large, serves to trap the molecule against the container surface. Because adsorption takes place, at equilibrium the benzene pressure inside an activated charcoal container will be much less than expected from the ideal gas equation.


next up previous
Next: P from the partition function Up: Chapter 6 Previous: Chapter 6

Nicholas V Sushkin
Sun Jun 30 15:18:58 EDT 1996